15 November 2026

Why is UFO secrecy so stable? A systems view

Intro: The puzzle

Here is a puzzle. Over the past (almost) ten years, the UFO issue has moved from the fringe toward the mainstream. The US Congress held hearings, the Pentagon created UAP offices, transparency laws were suggested, and people and mainstream media have been watching (or have they?). 

And yet, much of reality feels strangely unchanged. Serious scientific studies and lively public conversations about the UFO issue are still relatively rare outside the niche of UFO afficionados. Original data continues to be scarce in the public domain. The world suffers from wars, corrupt institutions, environmental crises, and social inequalities as before 2017.

So what has changed regarding the perception of the UFO issue among the powers at be and citizens around the world? Are we on a path to an official acknowledgement that we are not alone? Or is the trend pointing towards less official openness and courage regarding the UFO issue?

My goal with this post is not so much to answer those questions. The aim of this text is to introduce a conceptual framework for exploring the above posed questions.

Furthermore, the framework described below can give you a general sense of how and why the UFO secrecy seems immune to daylight, and what it can take to trigger a transition from the current UFO-situation to an open and honest global disclosure. Or instead of "disclosure", I prefer to view it as a (global) "sense-making process" in relation to the revelation that we are not alone.

The Multi-Level Perspective, a conceptual framework

The Multi-Level Perspective (the MLP) was developed by the Dutch transition researcher Frank Geels to explain a basic question: why is it so hard to replace established systems (e.g., in transportation and energy), even when better alternatives exist? Geels and other researchers use the MLP to describe and explain the stability and change of a socio-technical system (the interdependencies between social organisations and technology). 

The main idea of Geels’ socio-technical system and the MLP approach is that stability and change occur through three interacting levels. Think of them as three layers of a layered cake, each with their own grade of structure and manageability (see Figure 1 further down).

I have modified my description below of  Geels’ three-layered socio-technical system to fit the purpose of this post, but I have kept the essential points. Below the description, you will find a visualisation of the Multi-Level Perspective by Geels and Shots (2007), i.e., Figure 1.

1. The Landscape: the slow, enveloping, and uncontrollable background (macro-level). At the top of Figure 1 is the landscape with its broad, long-term developments and influences that no single actor controls, like demographic changes, major economic shifts, geopolitical tensions, or cultural attitudes. The landscape changes slowly, but when it shifts, it puts pressure on the regime (see layer nr. 2). Here you can also add how climate change, the space race, the AI race, and the unpredictability of the UFO phenomena can influence the regime (Geels’ framework does not include the UFO issue).

2. The Regime: the “rules of the game” (meso-level). The middle level is the established, dominant way of doing things in a specific society, for example, political and economic institutions or sub-regimes. Geels emphasises that the regime and its sub-regimes comprises rules which come in different functions: formal rules (laws, policies, regulations), normative rules (expectations, roles, behavior), and cognitive rules (what people think of as credible, taken-for-granted or possible).

All these “rules” (or logics) are path dependent and contingent. That is, the rules have a social history, and their outcomes are not inevitable (i.e., things could be different). A “dynamically stable” regime does not imply that there are no tensions or conflicts within or between different sub-regimes. However, the regime is stable – or taken-for-granted – because the institutions and citizens reproduce the configuration of the rules in their everyday sense-making and actions. You can think of the relation between agency and structure (rules, institutions) as dialectical: humans externalise their meaning and actions, which over time become institutionalised and objectified. The latter means that the socially constructed rules act back upon consciousness as a natural and objective reality (Berger & Luckmann, 1966).

Put differently, we are socialised into and have internalised the rules of the game of the specific regime/society into which we were born, which facilitates social coordination and cohesion. Would you stop the car at a red light, alone in the traffic in the middle of the night? If yes, then you have evidence that "society lives in you" as much as you live in society. You exist and act through a dialectical loop between your inner world and the outer world, or everyday reality.

3. Niches: the protected spaces of innovation (micro-level). At the bottom of the socio-technical system are niches: small, protected spaces where alternative knowledge, technologies, science, etc., are tested (e.g., think of the long history of AI-development before it went mainstream). Niches are a part of the dominant regime, but the people, communities, start-ups, etc., in the niche-layer are usually interested in changing the rules of the established regime. Niche actors often work with little funding and little recognition. Most niches never break through. They survive because they are sheltered from the harsh rules of the dominant regime and/or because the regime, or a sub-regime, can utilise and profit from the innovations coming from the niches. 

How change happens or stability persists

According to the MLP-framework, a transition happens when three conditions align. Niches develop innovations that are ready to be adopted by the regime. Landscape pressure put a strain on the regime. And the regime itself shows cracks, “windows of opportunity”, where innovations can enter. If any of these conditions for change are missing, the regime absorbs the pressure and carries on, often with minor adjustments that leave the deep structure (e.g., ontological assumptions) intact. In other words, timing is crucial for changes to occur in established paradigms in the regime.

The latter makes the Multiple-Level Perspective (MLP) useful for our initial puzzle. It is a framework about why things stay the same, not only about how they change. Below is the original figure of the MLP by Geels and Shot (2007). 


Figure 1. The Multi-Level Perspective (Geels & Schot, 2007) is a framework to identify the elements of a complex system and to analyse how and why the interactions between the elements on multiple levels reproduce stability or lead to radical change of the regime (e.g., sustainability transitions of energy sources). Pressures from the landscape and/or the niche-layer can open windows of opportunity in the regime, which might result in major changes in the rules of the game.

If you want to grasp the MLP-framework better and practically, I recommend this up-to-date article by Frank W. Geels: 

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/386409161_The_Multi-Level_Perspective_on_Sustainability_Transitions_Background_overview_and_current_research_topics.

Or you can watch Geels' presentation (32 minutes) on the MLP here. When watching the presentation, try to think of what system the UFO issue is embedded in, and how to crack open the "regime of UFO secrecy."

For our purpose, we can use the MLP to ask if and to what degree the transparency efforts after 2017 have created any cracks in the regime of UFO secrecy. We can ask, for example, to what extent and intensity has the UFO issue become a serious, prioritised political and existential consideration in the world since 2017? 

 Or what relevant elements (institutions, rules, actors) have to align, and in what sequence should decisions and interventions occur to increase the pressure on the regime of UFO secrecy? Remember that according to the MLP, timing is everything. 

The two following sections, influenced by the MLP, might help to explore why the regime of UFO secrecy has been and still is so stable. 

The “regime of UFO secrecy” and why it is so persistent

Normally, the MLP is used to study a transition that happened, like the move from horse-drawn carriages to automobiles. Here we turn it around and explore why a transition from UFO secrecy to global UFO disclosure has not happened. Stability is the puzzle, especially post-2017 (e.g., credible testimony from military- and intelligence insiders).

Figure 2 below suggests that the current “regime of UFO secrecy” has mainly absorbed and adapted to transparency pressures rather than undergone deep structural changes. However, it does not mean that the current UFO-situation is the same as pre-2017 or that no positive changes have occurred. It has, but it is hard to get an overview of where in the world, for whom, and in what ways the UFO issue has become a salient topic to prioritise in a busy everyday reality, and for many, even worse.


Figure 2: An AI-creation influenced by the original from Geels & Shot (2007). Figure 2 suggests that after 2017 (the right panel) the regime of UFO secrecy has remained protected rather than changed, despite transparency pressures from within and the outside. The green dotted line around the "core rules" (e.g., classification) of the regime indicates that so far, the regime has adjusted to various threats to the status quo. How can actors in the niche-layer create powerful pressure on the regime? What influences from the landscape could seriously shake the regime of UFO secrecy? How to engage ordinary citizens in the UFO issue? The MPL-framework also asks about the right timing and sequencing of decisions and actions that could shake the stability of UFO secrecy.


The key aspect to understand regarding the stability of the UFO secrecy is how the interactions between the different institutions (or sub-regimes) reproduce business as usual at the regime-level. Each institution/sub-regime follow their own rules (formal, normative, and cognitive) which intentionally or unintentionally can co-evolve with other institutions at the regime-level. 

That parallel co-evolution can create and maintain patterns of “lock-ins”, which can be hard to break since these patterns are perceived as natural ("this is how we do it") and right in a normative or moral sense by the actors in the regime or a sub-regime. Then, there are formal rules which the actors draw upon to legitimise decisions and actions (the enabling aspect of rules) and simultaneously constrain actors' attention to and cognition of alternative ways of viewing and doing things.

For example, take the interactions between political power and science. If the original UFO data is classified or made public without official analysis or conclusions, scientists cannot study it. If scientists cannot study it, the UFO issue struggles with ontological and epistemological legitimacy. And without that legitimacy, there is little outside pressure to release anything substantial. The logic of the respective sub-regimes contradicts each other but also reproduces the locked-in situation of the status of the UFO issue. 

Put differently, the outcome of the interaction (or the lack thereof) between science and political power is a "lock-in" situation where the UFO issue ever reaches enough legitimacy. The UFO issue is kept in a liminal space of "half-fringe" and "half-credible", which probably makes it easy for politicians, scientists, and citizens not to prioritise the UFO issue. 

On an aggregate level, the interactions between sub-regimes involved in the UFO issue create and maintain a dynamically stable regime of UFO secrecy. The underlying rules of the game of each sub-regime drives the dynamic of the interactions and their outcomes (e.g., "lock-in" situations). 

Thus, here is a question of a deliberate cover-up or bureaucratic inertia, and/or the lack of coordination and trust between sub-regimes involved in the UFO issue.

 What could destabilise the “regime of UFO secrecy”?

The obvious question then becomes: How can we open these lock-ins? As I have written in a previous post, I believe a necessary condition is a top-down ontological acknowledgement that we are not alone. This would give the UFO issue legitimacy and humanity permission to be curious about the UFO phenomena without fear of social stigma.

That is, the rules and power of a sub-regime can be both enabling or constraining. With an official ontological acknowledgement, political power could enable UFO transparency and global disclosure, or a global sense-making process. Ultimately, disclosure could have radical effects on our current socio-technical systems (e.g., energy sources, socio-economic inequalities, etc.), but the outcomes of disclosure are contingent on numerous prerequisites and conditions.

However, remember that transitions rarely happen because one pressure on one level grows strong. Change happens when three conditions align, according to the MLP: Landscape pressure strains the regime, niches have innovations ready to offer, and the regime itself shows cracks. Transition researchers call such a moment a window of opportunity. Windows open, and they also close. 

So are we living in an opening up-moment of the UFO secrecy or controlled transparency by the dominant regime?

Here, the MLP-framework gives us two interpretations, and it might be too early to choose which one of them accurately describes the current situation:

The opening-up interpretation: the regime is cracking from within. Too much UFO material is moving into public view. Several factions compete over glory and profit, and a topic once handled quietly or with ridicule now has an official website. This pathway could lead to releases of substantial data that can be independently verified and to a top-down ontological acknowledgement that we are not alone.

The adjustment interpretation: the regime responds to pressure with procedures it controls, on its own timetable, without changing the rules that decide how evidence is handled. This pathway is maintaining, or protecting, the status quo regarding the consequential data on and implications of the UFO issue for the current world order.  

Both interpretations fit the current UFO-situation so far. I leave it up to the reader to decide which one fits the most or seems most probable. 

However, note that Figure 2 suggests the adjustment interpretation, which I will qualify in the last section. One way to differentiate between the two interpretations is to focus on what happens next. Keep in mind that one push at one level of the system might not be sufficient to direct the UFO issue onto a pathway that increases the chances of global UFO disclosure.

Takeaways

Let us gather the threads. We started with a puzzle: why has not growing attention to the UFO issue led to greater clarity on what governments, the military, and private contractors know about the UFO issue? Through the lens of the MLP, this post has explored the puzzle of the stability of UFO secrecy. The exploration can be summarised as follows.

The stability of UFO secrecy is a regime thing, not a conspiracy. The (mis)management of the UFO issue is reproduced by several sub-regimes, each following its own rules of the game. The persistent UFO secrecy is because of path dependency (e.g., decisions made in the late 1940s and early 1950s) and of current interactions (or lack thereof) between sub-regimes that maintain the status quo of almost eight decades. With that said, let us not forget that the UFO issue is in a better place today compared to before 2017. Still, the question remains what that "better place" means, for whom, where in the world, etc.

More evidence does not break the lock-ins by itself. Evidence is rerouted into existing procedures (controlled releases), reframed by ordinary explanations (sometimes, official debunking), and so on. Data only counts as evidence when there is an infrastructure to conduct independent evaluation.

Windows open, and they close. For example, the 2026 PURSUE-initiative looks like such a window, but whether it is an opening or a case of controlled transparency depends on what happens next. The negative aspect of this is the complexity of the system, which makes it hard to judge what will happen next (i.e., "opening-up", adjustment", or something else). The positive side is that everyone can make up their own mind about the UFO issue, regardless of what their government says or does in the matter. For actors in the niche-layer, coalition-building and collective action are probably the most powerful ways to put pressure on the regime and create a window of opportunity.

The central question of this post has been: What path are we currently travelling, i.e., more openness or more business as usual? What and how can reinforce openness and destabilise continued UFO secrecy? 

Another way to put the "puzzle" is that the UFO secrecy is highly institutionalised/structured, but the UFO issue is not: as a subject, it is still highly fragmented, ontologically contested ("real or not?"), and stigmatised. At least, from the perspective of 99 % of the world's population (which is understandable, considering how the world is and looks). 

One question then becomes: Could an ontological acknowledgement that we are not alone facilitate the world fighting corruption, poverty, wars, and environmental issues? Or must our world become more fair and peaceful before the UFO issue can have a prominent place in people's consciousness? 

The point of introducing the MLP-framework was to explore those and other questions through a systems view. 

Strengths and limits of the MLP-framework

The MLP-framework can explain why the institutional response to the UFO issue has been so stable over the decades, and it gives us questions to ask about how to change the situation. That is a strength, but it also marks a boundary: structure explains stability, not what truly lies behind UFO secrecy. A literal cover-up and mundane bureaucratic inertia are all possible, and they are not mutually exclusive with an institutional story. Figure 2 does not include or exclude "core secrets" (e.g., recovered ET-craft) as causes of the stability of the UFO secrecy.

The true causes of decades of UFO secrecy, however, raise important questions about strategy, kinds of interventions, sequencing, etc., in order to crack open the dominant regime.

Another caveat is that the MLP-framework is designed to explain technological transitions such as energy systems. Because applying the MLP to the UFO issue extends beyond its design, this post aimed to explore the secrecy's stability rather than provide an explanation or a conclusion.

After all, the point of this post was to introduce a conceptual tool (the MLP) that hopefully can be useful when thinking about the causes of the stability of the UFO secrecy and about possibilities for change. 

The massive structure and power of the regime of UFO secrecy can make you feel powerless and hopeless. That is understandable. But why give away your agency and sense of purpose to a socially constructed regime? Things can be different.

Yes, "society lives in you", so you are constrained by decades of socialisation and internalisation of all kinds of rules. On the other hand, you also live and act within and through society. You know the rules of the game. Rules can also be enabling. And the world could be different. What if X, Y, and Z ---> global disclosure? 

(Pssst...,listen. Complex systems do not have linear causes and effects. Don't worry, we'll figure out the non-linear stuff, emergence, interdependencies, and so on. Take care!).


References


Peter Berger and Thomas Luckmann. (1966). The Social Construction of Reality. A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge. 

Frank W. Geels and Johan Shot. (2007). 
Typology of sociotechnical transition pathways. Research Policy 36, 399 - 417. 

No comments: